Carrier comparison
Progressive vs. AAA Car Insurance in Michigan: Which Fits?
Progressive has the lower available Michigan sample for a driver with one DUI: $254 a month versus $463 for AAA’s Auto Club Group. That does not establish the cheaper company for a clean-record household. AAA has more positive national claims feedback and Michigan loan-gap and vehicle-replacement options; include membership dues when comparing your own offers.
Compair Editorial Review
Which is the better fit for you?
A lower DUI-profile sample and a clearly described loan-payoff option.
More positive national claims feedback and a membership roadside plan.
Which may be cheaper? Progressive is $209 a month lower in the specific DUI sample below. No matched clean-record Michigan price pair was established. Your driving history, PIP choice and collision coverage can change the result.
| Driver profile | Progressive | AAA / Auto Club Group |
|---|---|---|
| One DUI | $254 | $463 |
This is a DUI profile, not a typical clean-record price. The $209 monthly difference is a sample comparison, not promised savings. No matching clean-record AAA price was established.
About these sample prices
Third-party modeled rates from public filings; article updated November 2, 2026 and checked November 4. The sample uses 35-year-old men and women, a 2023 Toyota Camry LE, 12,000 annual miles and one DUI. Monthly figures are medians.
Published limits: $100,000/$300,000 bodily injury, $50,000 property damage, $100,000/$300,000 uninsured-motorist bodily injury and $1,000 comprehensive/collision deductibles. Required additional coverages were added, but the exact Michigan PIP selection, collision form, violation timing, legal issuer and insurer sample counts are not disclosed. The generic good-credit research profile is not permission to price Michigan auto insurance on credit. Compair did not collect these quotes.
AAA requires membership for Michigan insurance. Include any additional dues in the household total.
AAA membership costs and roadside benefits
| Plan | Dues | Towing benefit |
|---|---|---|
| Classic | $79 | Provider’s shop or 5 miles |
| Plus | $117 | Up to 100 miles |
| Premier | $144 | One 200-mile tow; others up to 100 miles |
ZIP-based prices, household additions, fees and renewal offers can differ. Roadside restrictions and waiting periods apply. These are membership services, not insurance premiums. Check your final price and AAA’s current plan terms.
The differences that matter
Coverage and day-to-day service
Compare the protections you would use and the help you would want after a loss. Optional features cost extra and may depend on your Michigan policy.
Who insures your car
ProgressiveMichigan complaint records identify Progressive Marathon and Progressive Michigan. Match your proposal to the legal company, not just the Progressive logo.
AAAAAA’s current Michigan page identifies MemberSelect Insurance Company for auto. Older policies and complaint tables also include other Auto Club companies.
Driving monitoring
ProgressiveSnapshot replaces the initial participation discount with a result based on driving at renewal; some drivers pay more. Ask for the Michigan enrollment terms and a quote without monitoring.
AAAThe June 2026 AAADrive FAQ includes Michigan and says the household score can raise or lower premium. Confirm whether your policy uses this newer program.
Financed or leased car
ProgressiveOptional loan/lease payoff generally pays up to 25% of the vehicle’s value toward the remaining eligible debt after a covered total loss; comprehensive and collision are required. State limits can differ.
AAAThe Michigan menu lists optional Loan Lease Gap and Enhanced Total Loss Replacement. Ask for the gap cap, excluded debt and vehicle-age/mileage conditions; a new-car replacement option is a different benefit.
A rental while your car is repaired
ProgressiveRental reimbursement is optional, requires comprehensive and collision, and applies after a covered loss. Select a realistic daily allowance and maximum duration.
AAARequest the policy’s rental allowance and duration. Accident Assist can arrange a rental, but arranging it does not establish that the full bill is insured.
Roadside help
ProgressivePrice the optional roadside coverage separately. You can also keep AAA membership while buying Progressive insurance; do not pay twice for benefits you do not need.
AAAMembership roadside benefits follow the member in eligible vehicles, subject to club terms. Towing distance depends on Classic, Plus or Premier; membership is separate from collision and rental coverage.
Students and household savings
ProgressiveProgressive describes good-student and student-away discounts. Its college guide uses full-time students under 23 with a B average or better; confirm Michigan eligibility and the actual dollar reduction.
AAAAsk about young-driver, good-student, student-away, multicar and membership-tenure savings. The public benefits list is dated July 2022, so its thresholds are questions for the agent, not verified current Michigan entitlements.
Working with the insurer
ProgressiveProgressive supports online claims reporting and tracking. Ask who handles repairs, supplements and rental extensions for your policy.
AAAAAA offers agents and claim services. The stronger national claims response is useful context, but neither it nor membership service measures Michigan claim speed.
Match Michigan coverage before comparing price
Match PIP medical limits and any permitted exclusions using each household member’s health coverage. A lower PIP selection has eligibility conditions and can shift medical costs to you; an insurance card alone does not establish qualified health coverage. Keep liability, uninsured/underinsured motorist limits, comprehensive and collision choices consistent.
Collision example: $3,000 of covered damage with a $1,000 standard-collision deductible leaves $1,000 for you and $2,000 for the insurer. Broad collision waives the deductible when you are 50% or less at fault; in that case the covered $3,000 is payable. Above 50% fault, the deductible applies. Limited collision can leave your car damage uninsured when you are substantially at fault. These are Michigan coverage choices, not carrier-specific promises.
Rental example: a $50 daily allowance against a $65 rental leaves $15 a day for you, or $150 over ten covered days, before any other fees. Ask about the total limit and when payments stop. Roadside towing and loan-gap coverage solve different problems.
Coverage details and sources
Current Michigan policy forms and eligibility control the actual offer. National coverage descriptions identify questions to ask; they do not establish default inclusion, every exclusion or a guaranteed local benefit.
- AAA Michigan insurers and vehicle options
- AAA Michigan membership requirement
- AAA claims service
- Current AAADrive FAQ, including Michigan
- AAA benefits and discounts (dated July 2022)
- AAA member handbook
- Progressive Snapshot
- Progressive loan/lease payoff
- Progressive rental reimbursement
- Progressive student guidance
- Michigan collision law, section 500.3037
- Michigan DIFS auto insurance guidance
Reviewed November 4, 2026. Many carrier pages are undated. AAA’s new driving FAQ was updated June 9, 2026 and its insurance FAQ August 4. The older AAA discount list is not evidence of today’s Michigan qualification rules. Obtain current endorsement and driving-program terms before enrolling.
Questions to settle before you buy
Can I keep AAA roadside and buy the other insurer’s policy?
Yes. Membership and car insurance are separate purchases. Check the member handbook and the other policy’s roadside option to avoid paying for unnecessary overlap.
Will turning off driving monitoring remove its effect on my price?
Do not assume so. Ask for the enrollment, withdrawal and score-reset rules for your policy version. A stored score or loss of a participation discount can affect later pricing.
Is gap coverage the same as rental reimbursement?
No. Gap/payoff addresses eligible debt after a total loss. Rental coverage addresses temporary transportation after a covered loss, within its limits.
Claims and reliability
What the service evidence tells you
What surveyed customers said
National third-party auto survey responses for the 2026 edition, based on 2025 research. These are customer opinions, not Michigan claim-payment rates or Compair ratings.
| Positive response | Progressive | AAA / Auto Club Group |
|---|---|---|
| Claims handling | 62% | 84% |
| Overall satisfaction | 78% | 89% |
| Ease of service | 86% | 81% |
Auto Club Group has the higher claims and overall responses; Progressive has the higher ease-of-service response. This supports a service trade-off, not a claim that one company pays Michigan claims faster.
How to read the survey
The publisher commissioned online research through Dynata; its methodology describes more than 2,000 insurance consumers overall, not that many customers for each company. The auto article’s introduction says “nearly 2,000,” while its method says “more than 2,000”; exact product and brand counts are not supplied.
Michigan samples, brand counts, recent-claimant counts, detailed weighting and confidence intervals are not published. The claims question is not an audit of paid claims. These recruited respondents differ from people who choose to post public reviews. Only raw response percentages are used, not the publisher’s composite rating. Checked November 4, 2026.
The AAA figures are specifically for Auto Club Group, which serves Michigan. They are not Auto Club Enterprises or CSAA results, and they do not isolate MemberSelect or Auto Club Insurance Association.
Michigan complaints: look beyond one year
MemberSelect’s auto complaint ratio was 0.12 in 2023, 0.15 in 2024 and 0.13 in 2025. Progressive Marathon moved from 0.20 to 0.16; Progressive Michigan from 0.15 to 0.09. The Progressive companies straddle MemberSelect in 2025, so a single brand-wide complaint winner would hide an important difference.
Ratios are complaints per $1 million of Michigan premium, not claim outcomes or satisfaction scores. Match the legal company on your proposal.
Michigan complaint trends, 2023–2025
Each ratio is complaints divided by Michigan written premium, multiplied by $1 million. A growing premium denominator can lower a ratio even while complaints rise. These are selected legal insurers, not brand totals or claims-only measures.
Progressive
| Year | Complaints | MI premium | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 284 | $1,386,435,466 | 0.20 |
| 2024 | 294 | $1,588,737,596 | 0.19 |
| 2025 | 271 | $1,716,509,102 | 0.16 |
| Year | Complaints | MI premium | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 122 | $840,507,196 | 0.15 |
| 2024 | 107 | $982,586,844 | 0.11 |
| 2025 | 88 | $968,481,527 | 0.09 |
AAA
| Year | Complaints | MI premium | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 93 | $801,902,114 | 0.12 |
| 2024 | 153 | $992,161,351 | 0.15 |
| 2025 | 132 | $1,031,497,944 | 0.13 |
| Year | Complaints | MI premium | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 21 | $18,326,222 | 1.15 |
| 2024 | 17 | $17,881,372 | 0.95 |
| 2025 | 23 | $15,891,601 | 1.45 |
| Year | Complaints | MI premium | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 14 | $169,187,982 | 0.08 |
| 2024 | 33 | $162,519,007 | 0.20 |
| 2025 | 13 | $143,503,737 | 0.09 |
A missing row is not zero complaints. DIFS publishes ratios for companies with at least $1 million in premium. Legacy companies are retained for readers with older policies; current AAA marketing names MemberSelect for Michigan auto and Auto Club Insurance Association for Michigan home.
Source: Michigan DIFS, checked November 4, 2026. 2023 auto table 2024 auto table 2025 auto table · Consumer analysis only; DIFS does not endorse these recommendations. These are not NAIC complaint indexes.
Financial context: use the legal company
Reported surplus is a financial cushion above recorded liabilities. The selected insurers report positive surplus in DIFS’s 2025 annual report, but the amounts alone cannot rank safety.
Reported financial cushion by insurer
Progressive
- Progressive Marathon Insurance Company: $649.9 million
- Progressive Michigan Insurance Company: $524.3 million
AAA
- MemberSelect Insurance Company: $151.2 million
- Auto Club Insurance Association: $2.77 billion
- Auto Club Group Insurance Company: $120.1 million
Historical company-wide amounts, not Michigan-only claim funds or current financial-strength ratings. Size, risks and reinsurance differ. A partner home insurer cannot be assessed using Progressive’s auto companies; State Farm General is different from State Farm Fire and Casualty.
DIFS 2025 annual report, PDF pages 41, 43, 51 and 81. Source amounts are thousands of dollars; these displays convert to millions/billions. Checked November 4, 2026.
Independent review snapshot
What customers report
AAA uses a regional BBB customer average; the other brand uses a national Trustpilot TrustScore. Different sources and customers: compare with care.
Progressive
1.2out of 5
2,024 reviews
National brand; multiple insurance products.
Source snapshot: November 3, 2026.
AAA Michigan
1.05out of 5
75 reviews in this snapshot
Michigan headquarters and corporate locations; insurance and membership services. Not BBB’s letter grade.
Source snapshot: November 2, 2026.
About these public reviews
Source snapshots reviewed November 4, 2026. Scores and counts change; these are retrieved snapshots, not a live feed. BBB counts differed across retrieved snapshots; the linked snapshot is used here. These are third-party customer signals, not Compair scores, Michigan auto policy ratings or measures of claims paid.
What to take from public reviews
These reviews can flag service problems to ask about. They are not the same as the national survey above: people choose whether to post, and the scores mix products and locations. Use them alongside Michigan complaints and a conversation with the agent who would help you.
See 2025 Michigan complaint ratios for the legal insurers
Complaints per $1 million of Michigan written premium, as reported by DIFS. Lower means fewer complaints relative to premium; it does not measure claim speed, payouts or proven wrongdoing.
Progressive
- Progressive Marathon Insurance Company
271 complaints / $1,716,509,102 written premium - 0.16
- Progressive Michigan Insurance Company
88 complaints / $968,481,527 written premium - 0.09
AAA
- Auto Club Group Insurance Company
- 0.09
- Auto Club Insurance Association
- 1.45
- MemberSelect Insurance Company
- 0.13
Source: DIFS 2025 automobile table, retrieved November 4, 2026. Selected named entities, not every affiliate. Match the company on your quote. DIFS lists companies with at least $1 million in premium; these are not NAIC complaint indexes or endorsements.
Ask both insurers who handles your claim, how you track it and how to dispute an estimate. Test the actual agent’s responsiveness before buying.
Beyond the first quote
Which is more likely to raise your rate?
There is no reliable way to name the lower-renewal insurer from this evidence. A first-year quote, a customer review or a plan to renew does not tell you how much your next price will rise. Compare your renewal offer with fresh quotes for the same coverage.
Ask Progressive
Request the premium before and after Snapshot, any expiring discounts, fees and changes to drivers or vehicles. Compare the actual policy term rather than assuming a year.
Ask AAA
For the newer AAADrive program, Michigan driving data is collected for up to two terms; the resulting score can continue at later renewals unless you reenroll to update it. Ask how withdrawal affects pricing.
At renewal, compare the same term length, limits, deductibles and payment plan. Separate insurer rate changes from changes to your household, property, coverage or discounts. Review the renewal before cancelling any existing coverage.
Make the decision
Which is better for your situation?
You have a DUI on your record
Start by pricing Progressive
It is lower in the matched published DUI profile. Get AAA’s quote too: the model does not capture your exact violation date, vehicles or PIP choice.
You already use AAA roadside
Compare the insurance on its own merits
Keep membership in either scenario if you would buy it anyway. Count only the additional membership cost caused by your insurance choice.
You owe more than the car is worth
Compare the payoff in dollars
Ask Progressive to calculate its cap and AAA to show the gap endorsement. Check whether rolled-over debt, fees and your deductible are excluded.
You want help after a crash
Include AAA and test the service contact
Auto Club Group has the higher national claims response. Ask both carriers how to reach an adjuster and approve a rental extension.
You are adding a student driver
Price the full household with both
Ask about grades, where the student lives and whether a car goes to school. No matched Michigan teen-price winner is established here.
You dislike driving tracking
Request both prices without telematics
Compare a non-monitored quote before enrolling. A sign-up discount is not a promise that later driving-based pricing will be lower.
Progressive is the lower-price starting point for the published DUI profile; AAA deserves attention for claims feedback, membership services and Michigan vehicle options. For a clean-record driver, the actual matched quotes must settle price. Choose the coverage and contact route you would want after a loss.
Fit guidance is Compair’s editorial interpretation of the documented options and buying channels. Carrier access and eligibility vary; a Compair request may not include both insurers or every insurer in the market.
Ready to compare your own options?
Have your current coverage summary, driver and vehicle details, loan balance and desired rental allowance ready. Request the full-term price, payment fees and prices with and without driving monitoring.
Compair’s comparison service is free for consumers. There is no obligation to buy. Share your information through one intake. We help you review available prices and coverage, and you decide which policy you prefer. Additional information or assistance may be needed to complete quotes and buy coverage. The available insurers depend on your circumstances; neither named insurer is guaranteed to be included. Starting an intake does not bind a policy.
About the planning examples below
The 12-month checkpoint is an annual planning reminder, not your policy’s term. Compare at each actual renewal. The $6,579 health-deductible threshold alone does not establish qualified health coverage or eligibility for a PIP selection.
Coverage numbers and examples for matching your quotes
Progressive vs AAA Car Insurance in Michigan Helpful Numbers
Scan these helpful numbers before reading the detailed sections. Each one answers a different quote or coverage question for this page.
Use the visual to narrow the decision, then compare the two companies with matching inputs. A cheaper carrier is not a better carrier if the coverage, deductible, or support path changed.
Research transparency Sources & Methodology See the regulators, official materials, review dates, and limitations behind this guide.
Compair prioritizes Michigan regulators, government data, official carrier materials, and established independent research. We use these sources to explain shopping factors—not to predict the price or eligibility of an individual quote.
- Auto Insurance Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services · Michigan auto-insurance rules and consumer guidance
- Michigan Auto Insurance Frequently Asked Questions Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services · Current required coverage, PIP medical options, eligibility, and documentation
- Michigan Auto Insurance Consumer Guides State of Michigan · Michigan no-fault coverage and shopping guidance
- Auto Insurance National Association of Insurance Commissioners · General auto-insurance coverage and shopping context
- 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study J.D. Power · Independent national and North Central regional satisfaction research; not pricing or a Compair ranking
- Insurance Products Progressive · Official carrier product information
- Michigan Insurance Information AAA Michigan · Official Michigan auto coverage and carrier terminology
How to read the figures on this page
- Coverage and shopping guidance is checked against regulator, government, and official carrier materials before independent market research is used.
- Research sources were last reviewed October 25, 2026. A source review date is not the publication date of every underlying dataset.
- Auto examples are directional only. Premiums vary by driver, vehicle, permitted geographic territory, coverage, deductibles, discounts, and underwriting. Michigan prohibits using ZIP codes to set auto rates; insurers may use territories that are not defined by ZIP code. A dataset grouped by ZIP code does not establish a lawful individual rating factor.
- Market averages and examples are not quotes, guarantees, recommendations, or a substitute for policy documents.
See our full editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.
FAQs
Is Progressive or AAA better for online shoppers?
Progressive is usually a useful comparison for shoppers who prefer digital quoting and usage-based options. AAA may be worth comparing when membership benefits and regional support matter.
Does AAA membership automatically make AAA cheaper?
No. Membership can be relevant, but final price depends on drivers, vehicles, coverage, discounts, and eligibility.
Should I compare Snapshot against AAA benefits?
Yes, if those features matter to you. Snapshot-style driving data and AAA membership benefits are different value propositions.
What is the cleanest comparison?
Use the same coverage, deductibles, drivers, vehicles, address, PIP choice, and payment details before judging price.
How does Compair help me compare insurance quotes?
Compair Insurance Quotes LLC is an independent Michigan insurance agency. Start with one online request and your current coverage details so available insurer options can be reviewed using the same information. Carrier access and eligibility vary; a comparison does not include every insurer in the market.
Is it free to request and compare quotes with Compair?
Yes. Requesting and comparing quotes through Compair is free, with no obligation to buy. If you choose a policy, you pay the applicable insurance premium.
What happens after I request quotes through Compair?
Your request starts a review of your insurance needs. Additional information or documents may be needed before quotes are ready. Compare the coverage, deductibles, price and issuing insurer before choosing. Submitting a request does not bind coverage; confirm acceptance and the effective date before cancelling an existing policy.
Compare the Companies With Your Own Details
Use Compair to move from brand comparison into a quote comparison based on your actual Michigan household.
Compare Available Auto Quotes